Surfshark vs Private Internet Access (PIA)

Surfshark Surfshark
VS
Private Internet Access (PIA) Private Internet Access (PIA)
WINNER Surfshark

The comparison between Private Internet Access (PIA) and Surfshark is particularly compelling due to their contrasting a...

emoji_events WINNER
Surfshark

Surfshark

8.7 Very Good
VPN Service
VS

psychology AI Verdict

The comparison between Private Internet Access (PIA) and Surfshark is particularly compelling due to their contrasting approaches to user privacy, device support, and overall value. Private Internet Access (PIA) excels in its robust no-logs policy, which has been validated in court multiple times, giving users a strong sense of security regarding their data. Its extensive server network, comprising over 35,000 servers in 78 countries, ensures that users can find optimal connections for speed and reliability.

Additionally, PIA's open-source applications and features like the MACE ad/tracker/malware blocker enhance its appeal for privacy-conscious users. On the other hand, Surfshark stands out with its unique offering of unlimited simultaneous connections, making it an excellent choice for families or users with multiple devices. Surfshark's innovative Nexus network technology, which routes traffic through multiple servers, adds an extra layer of security that is not present in PIA's offerings.

While PIA is a strong contender for users focused on privacy and a proven track record, Surfshark's affordability and extensive feature set make it a better option for budget-conscious users and those who prioritize streaming capabilities. Ultimately, the choice between these two VPN services hinges on individual needs: PIA is ideal for those who prioritize privacy and a large server network, while Surfshark is better suited for users seeking value and flexibility across multiple devices.

emoji_events Winner: Surfshark
verified Confidence: High

thumbs_up_down Pros & Cons

Surfshark Surfshark

check_circle Pros

  • Unlimited simultaneous connections on a single subscription
  • Affordable pricing, especially for long-term plans
  • Innovative Nexus network technology for enhanced security
  • User-friendly interface suitable for all levels

cancel Cons

  • Fewer servers compared to PIA, with around 3,200 servers
  • Some users report occasional speed fluctuations
  • Limited advanced features compared to PIA
Private Internet Access (PIA) Private Internet Access (PIA)

check_circle Pros

  • Proven no-logs policy validated in court
  • Extensive server network with over 35,000 servers
  • Open-source applications enhance transparency
  • Powerful MACE ad/tracker/malware blocker

cancel Cons

  • Based in the United States, raising jurisdictional concerns
  • User interface may be complex for beginners
  • No unlimited device support

compare Feature Comparison

Feature Surfshark Private Internet Access (PIA)
Server Network Size Approximately 3,200 servers in 65 countries Over 35,000 servers in 78 countries
Simultaneous Connections Unlimited simultaneous connections Up to 10 simultaneous connections
No-Logs Policy No-logs policy, independently audited Proven no-logs policy validated in court
Ad/Tracker Blocker CleanWeb ad/tracker/malware blocker MACE ad/tracker/malware blocker
User Interface User-friendly and easy to navigate Straightforward but may overwhelm beginners
Pricing Structure $2.49/month for a 2-year plan $2.69/month for a 2-year plan

payments Pricing

Surfshark

$2.49/month for a 2-year plan
Excellent Value

Private Internet Access (PIA)

$2.69/month for a 2-year plan
Good Value

difference Key Differences

Surfshark Private Internet Access (PIA)
Surfshark's core strength lies in its unlimited simultaneous connections and innovative security features, appealing to families and users with multiple devices.
Core Strength
Private Internet Access (PIA) is renowned for its proven no-logs policy and extensive server network, making it a top choice for privacy-focused users.
Surfshark also delivers competitive speeds, often exceeding 75 Mbps on similar connections, but may experience slight slowdowns with its Nexus routing technology.
Performance
Private Internet Access (PIA) offers impressive speeds, particularly in regions with a high server density, achieving up to 80 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection.
Surfshark's pricing is highly attractive, especially given its unlimited device connections, making it a better value for families and multi-device users.
Value for Money
Private Internet Access (PIA) offers competitive pricing, especially for long-term subscriptions, but lacks the unlimited device support that enhances value.
Surfshark provides a user-friendly interface that is easy to navigate, making it accessible for users of all experience levels.
Ease of Use
Private Internet Access (PIA) has a straightforward interface, but some users may find its advanced features overwhelming at first.
Surfshark is best for budget-conscious users and families needing to connect multiple devices simultaneously.
Best For
Private Internet Access (PIA) is best for privacy-conscious users who value a proven no-logs policy and a large server network.

help When to Choose

Surfshark Surfshark
  • If you prioritize unlimited device connections
  • If you need a budget-friendly option
  • If you choose Surfshark if user-friendliness is important for your experience level
Private Internet Access (PIA) Private Internet Access (PIA)
  • If you prioritize a proven no-logs policy
  • If you need a large server network for optimal speeds
  • If you choose Private Internet Access (PIA) if advanced security features are important

description Overview

Surfshark

Surfshark stands out by offering unlimited simultaneous connections on a single subscription, making it incredibly cost-effective for families or users with many devices. It provides a comprehensive suite of features including CleanWeb (ad/tracker/malware blocker), a private search engine, and alert services for data breaches. Its Nexus network technology routes traffic through multiple servers fo...
Read more

Private Internet Access (PIA)

Private Internet Access (PIA) boasts one of the largest physical server networks and a long history in the VPN industry. Its no-logs policy has been proven multiple times in court when authorities requested data. All apps are now open-source, and it includes powerful features like its MACE ad/tracker/malware blocker and persistent port forwarding. Based in the United States (within the Five Eyes a...
Read more

swap_horiz Compare With Another Item

Compare Surfshark with...
Compare Private Internet Access (PIA) with...

Compare Items

See how they stack up against each other

Comparing
VS
Select 1 more item to compare