swap_horiz Feastables Cookies & Creme Alternatives

1

Amedei 9 Chocolate Bar

Amedei’s 9 bar utilizes nine different cacao beans from around the world, meticulously selected and blended to create a...

Luxury Dark Bar Blend

9.3 Excellent

2

Pump Street Sourdough & Sea Salt 66%

Pump Street Sourdough & Sea Salt 66% dark chocolate combines a rich, intensely flavored single-origin Valrhona dark choc...

Dark Sourdough Bar Sea Salt

9.1 Excellent

3

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate chip cookies are a baked good typically made with flour, butter, sugar, and chocolate chips, resulting in a so...

Classic American Baked Desserts

9.1 Excellent

4

Pump Street Croissant Bar 62%

Pump Street Chocolate’s 62% Cocoa Pump Street Croissant Bar combines flaky, buttery croissant dough with a rich, dark ch...

Croissant Dark Bar Pump Street

8.9 Great

5

Dick Taylor 72% Madagascar, Sambirano

Dick Taylor 72% Madagascar, Sambirano chocolate is crafted from cacao beans grown in the unique, humid forests of northe...

Dark Single Origin Bar Madagascar

8.8 Great

6

Amedei Toscano Black 70% Dark Chocolate

Amedei Toscano Black 70% is crafted from Peruvian Nacional cacao beans, known for their complex fruit and spice notes, r...

Italian Dark Bar 70 Cocoa

8.7 Great

7

Dandelion Chocolate Maya Mountain, Belize 85% 2023 Batch 1 Single-Origin Chocolate Bar

Dandelion Chocolate’s 2023 Batch 1 Maya Mountain bar utilizes cacao grown in the remote village of San Jose, Belize, fea...

Dark Single Origin Bar Belize

8.7 Great

8

Dandelion Chocolate Anamalai, India 70% 2022 Harvest Single-Origin Chocolate Bar

Dandelion Chocolate’s Anamalai, India 70% 2022 Harvest single-origin bar utilizes cacao beans grown in the Western Ghats...

India Dark Single Origin Bar

8.6 Great

9

Dandelion Chocolate Costa Esmeraldas, Ecuador 85% 2022 Batch 1 Single-Origin Chocolate Bar

Dandelion Chocolate’s 2022 Costa Esmeraldas batch utilizes cacao beans grown in the shaded forests of Ecuador's Esmerald...

Dark Single Origin Bar Ecuador

8.6 Great

10

Askinosie 77% Davao, Philippines Dark Chocolate Bar

Askinosie 77% Davao dark chocolate bars are crafted in the Philippines using beans grown on the slopes of Mount Talomo,...

Dark Single Origin Philippines Bar

8.6 Great

11

Pump Street Madagascar - Milk 58%

Pump Street Madagascar Milk contains 58% Madagascan dark chocolate, known for its fruity and complex flavor profile, com...

Single Origin Bar Madagascar Milk

8.6 Great

12

Askinosie 62% Dark Milk Chocolate + Fleur de Sel Sea Salt Bar

Askinosie’s 62% Dark Milk Chocolate bar combines ethically sourced Ecuadorian cacao with flakes of fleur de sel sea salt...

Single Origin Bar Sea Salt Dark Milk

8.5 Great

13

Ritual Bourbon Barrel Aged

Ritual Bourbon Barrel Aged Chocolate combines dark chocolate with notes of bourbon whiskey and vanilla, offering a compl...

Dark Bourbon Ritual Bar

8.5 Great

14

TWIX Caramel Full Size Candy Bar, 1.79oz

The TWIX Caramel Full Size Candy Bar contains two crisp biscuit bars dipped in milk chocolate and coated with caramel, o...

Caramel Bar Mars Milk

7.8 Good

15

Taza Chocolate Cookie Crunch 70% Dark Chocolate

Taza Chocolate Cookie Crunch features 70% dark chocolate combined with crispy, caramelized cookie pieces for a bitterswe...

Dark Bar Cookie 70 Percent

7.0 Good

16

Taza Lemon Cookie Crunch 70% Dark Chocolate

Taza Lemon Cookie Crunch dark chocolate combines 70% cacao with pieces of lemon-flavored shortbread cookies, offering a...

Dark Bar Cookie Taza

6.7 Fair

17

Feastables Peanut Butter

Feastables Peanut Butter Chocolate combines a rich dark chocolate shell with a smooth, intensely flavored peanut butter...

Bar Milk Peanut Butter Current

6.4 Fair

18

TWIX Chocolate Fudge Candy Bar

The Twix Chocolate Fudge Candy Bar consists of a biscuit bar coated in milk chocolate and sandwiched with a caramel fill...

Discontinued Bar Fudge Cookie

6.2 Fair

19

Feastables Caramel

Feastables Caramel Chocolate is a British confection made with real milk chocolate and chunks of caramel nougat, offerin...

Caramel Bar Milk Current

5.9 Mediocre

20

Feastables Milk Crunch

Feastables Milk Crunch is a chocolate bar featuring crispy milk chocolate pieces embedded within a smooth, creamy milk c...

Bar Milk Crunch Current

5.7 Mediocre