Smile (2022) vs Relic (2020)

Comparing Smile (2022) and Relic (2020) within the supernatural horror genre reveals two distinct approaches to eliciting dread, despite both achieving a remarkable 9.2/10 score. Smile (2022) distinguishes itself through a relentlessly visceral and visually arresting experience, largely driven by Sosuke Toges masterful direction and a deliberate, almost suffocating, use of unsettling imagery. The films core strength lies in its ability to generate a profound sense of unease through a meticulously crafted, almost painterly, aesthetic the use of distorted reflections, claustrophobic framing, and a color palette dominated by sickly greens and blues creates a truly immersive and disturbing atmosphere.

Furthermore, the films strategic deployment of jump scares, while present, serves primarily to punctuate the overwhelming psychological torment experienced by its protagonist, effectively amplifying the underlying sense of dread rather than relying solely on cheap thrills. Relic, conversely, adopts a slower, more deliberate pace, focusing on the disintegration of a family and the insidious nature of dementia, utilizing a hauntingly beautiful, yet deeply unsettling, sound design to build tension. While undeniably effective, Relics supernatural elements are presented with a subtlety that allows the film to resonate on a profoundly human level, exploring themes of guilt, regret, and familial obligation with a remarkable degree of emotional depth.

The films success hinges on the exceptional performances of its three leads, particularly Lori Pettys portrayal of the deteriorating matriarch, which elevates the entire experience. Ultimately, Smile (2022) offers a more immediate and intensely frightening experience, prioritizing immediate shock and psychological manipulation, while Relic (2020) provides a more sustained and emotionally resonant horror experience rooted in familial drama and the slow creep of decay. Considering these differences, Smile (2022) emerges as the superior choice for viewers seeking a truly immersive and unsettling cinematic experience, particularly those who appreciate bold visual storytelling and a relentless assault on the senses.

However, for those who prefer a more nuanced and character-driven horror experience, Relic (2020) provides a deeply rewarding and thought-provoking alternative.