swap_horiz Chapman's Tiger Tail Alternatives

1

Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

Graeter's Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip is the best-known flavor from Graeter's, a Cincinnati, Ohio ice cream company f...

Regional Pint Chocolate Chip Black Raspberry

9.1 Excellent

2

Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla

Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla is the flagship ice cream flavor of Blue Bell Creameries, founded in 1907 in Brenham, Texas....

Classic Regional Vanilla Pint

8.7 Great

3

Blue Bell Banana Pudding

Blue Bell Banana Pudding is an ice cream flavor produced by Blue Bell Creameries. It is modeled after the traditional So...

Regional Banana Southern Pint

8.4 Great

4

Graeter's Buckeye Chocolate Chip

Graeter's Buckeye Chocolate Chip is a regional specialty from Cincinnati-based Graeter's, combining peanut butter and ch...

Chocolate Regional Peanut Butter Pint

8.3 Great

5

Blue Bell Cookies 'n Cream

Blue Bell Cookies 'n Cream is a commercial ice cream flavor manufactured by Blue Bell Creameries, headquartered in Brenh...

Classic Regional Pint Cookies Cream

8.2 Great

6

Blue Bell Moo-llennium Crunch

Moo-llennium Crunch is a packaged ice cream flavor produced by Blue Bell Creameries, a regional dairy company headquarte...

Regional Caramel Nuts Pint

8.1 Great

7

Blue Bell Natural Vanilla Bean

Blue Bell Natural Vanilla Bean is a standard ice cream flavor produced by Blue Bell Creameries, a regional dairy company...

Simple Regional Vanilla Pint

8.1 Great

8

Graeter's Mint Chocolate Chip

Graeter's Mint Chocolate Chip is a longtime flavor from Graeter's of Cincinnati, Ohio, distinguished by the large chocol...

Mint Regional Pint Chocolate Chip

8.1 Great

9

Tillamook Oregon Strawberry

Tillamook Oregon Strawberry is a premium ice cream flavor produced by the Tillamook County Creamery Association, a farme...

Premium Regional Strawberry Pint

8.1 Great

10

Graeter's Coffee Toffee Chip

Graeter's Coffee Toffee Chip is a signature ice cream flavor produced by the Cincinnati-based Graeter's company. The fla...

Coffee Regional Toffee Pint

8.0 Great

11

Blue Bell Butter Pecan

Blue Bell Butter Pecan is a popular ice cream flavor produced by Blue Bell Creameries, a company founded in 1907 and hea...

Regional Nuts Pint Butter Pecan

7.9 Good

12

Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate

Blue Bell Dutch Chocolate is a chocolate ice cream produced by Blue Bell Creameries, a dairy company founded in 1907 and...

Classic Chocolate Regional Pint

7.8 Good

13

Graeter's Coconut Chocolate Chip

Graeter's Coconut Chocolate Chip is a flavor from Graeter's, the Cincinnati, Ohio creamery established in 1870, made usi...

Regional Coconut Pint Chocolate Chip

7.8 Good

14

Creamsicle Orange & Cream Bar

Creamsicle Orange & Cream Bar is an American frozen novelty combining orange-flavored ice with a vanilla ice cream cente...

Classic Orange Vanilla Bar

7.7 Good

15

Friendly's Forbidden Chocolate

Friendly's Forbidden Chocolate is a rich, deep chocolate ice cream flavor produced by the Friendly's restaurant chain, w...

Chocolate Regional Rich Pint

7.6 Good

16

Blue Bell Rocky Road

Blue Bell Rocky Road is a commercially produced ice cream flavor manufactured by Blue Bell Creameries, a regional dairy...

Chocolate Regional Marshmallow Pint

7.4 Good

17

Blue Bell Great Divide

Blue Bell Great Divide is a half-and-half ice cream flavor produced by Blue Bell Creameries, headquartered in Brenham, T...

Classic Regional Neapolitan Pint

7.3 Good

18

Turkey Hill Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Turkey Hill Dairy's Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup is a frozen dairy dessert manufactured by the Pennsylvania-based creamer...

Chocolate Regional Peanut Butter Pint

7.3 Good

19

Chapman's Maple Walnut

Chapman's Maple Walnut is a commercial ice cream flavor produced by Chapman's Ice Cream, a major Canadian dairy manufact...

Classic Canadian Walnut Maple

7.1 Good

20

Chapman's Neapolitan

Chapman's Neapolitan combines chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream in one package, produced by Chapman's Ice Cre...

Classic Canadian Neapolitan Pint

6.6 Fair