swap_horiz Old Amsterdam Alternatives

1

L'Amuse Signature Gouda

L’Amuse Signature Gouda is a handcrafted Dutch cheese made from cow’s milk. It’s notable for its crystalline texture dev...

Artisan Dutch Crystalline Cow Milk

9.20 Excellent

2

Reypenaer VSOP

Reypenaer VSOP is a complex Dutch hard cheese crafted primarily from cow’s milk. The brand, steeped in tradition, ages i...

Complex Brand Dutch Cow Milk

8.80 Great

3

Parmigiano Reggiano

Parmigiano Reggiano is a traditional Italian hard cheese produced exclusively within a designated area of Northern Italy...

Italian Dop Hard Cow Milk

8.79 Great

4

L'Etivaz

L’Etivaz is an artisan hard cheese originating in the Swiss Alps. Traditionally produced by local farmers using raw cow'...

Swiss Alpine Artisan Hard

8.79 Great

5

Roomano

Roomano is a Dutch hard cheese crafted from cow’s milk and known for its exceptionally long aging process—at least two y...

Brand Dutch Crunchy Cow Milk

8.70 Great

6

Le Gruyère AOP

Le Gruyère AOP is a traditional Alpine hard cheese produced in Switzerland. Its Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) ce...

Swiss Alpine Dop Hard

8.67 Great

7

Beemster Classic

The Beemster Classic is a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted using cow’s milk sourced from farms within the Beemster...

Brand Aged Dutch Butterscotch

8.65 Great

8

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an American artisan hard cheese crafted using alpine-style techniques. Produced by Upl...

American Artisan Hard Cow Milk

8.60 Great

9

Sbrinz AOP

Sbrinz AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from raw cow’s milk primarily sourced in the canton of Lucerne. Re...

Swiss Dop Hard Cow Milk

8.51 Great

10

Remeker Grand Cru

The Remeker Grand Cru is a distinctive Dutch hard cheese produced by De Groote Voort farm. Crafted using raw milk from J...

Artisan Dutch Hard Cow Milk

8.30 Great

11

Lekkerkerker Fermier Oude Kaas

Dutch raw-milk farmhouse aged Gouda from the Lekkerkerker family farm, a fermier cheese ripened to develop complex, cara...

Aged Dutch Hard Cow Milk

7.89 Good

12

Prima Donna

Prima Donna is a branded Dutch cow's-milk cheese produced in the style of a firm, matured Gouda while drawing comparison...

Brand Aged Dutch Cow Milk

7.85 Good

13

Beemster XO

Beemster XO is an extra-aged, pasteurized cow's milk Gouda cheese produced by the Beemster cooperative in the North Holl...

Aged Dutch Hard Cow Milk

7.77 Good

14

Black Bomber Cheddar

Black Bomber is an extra-mature, pasteurized cow's milk cheddar produced by the Snowdonia Cheese Company in Wales. It is...

British Branded Cheddar Hard

6.72 Fair

15

Leidse Oude Kaas

Leidse Oude Kaas is a Dutch cumin cheese associated with the Leiden region. It is made from partly skimmed cow’s milk, a...

Dutch Spiced Hard Cow Milk

6.62 Fair

16

Davidstow Cheddar

Davidstow Cheddar is a branded British cheddar made at the Davidstow creamery in Cornwall, in southwest England. It is a...

British Branded Cheddar Hard

6.44 Fair

17

Parrano

Parrano is a branded Dutch cow's-milk cheese produced by Uniekaas. It has a semi-hard, smooth texture modeled on young G...

Dutch Branded Cow Milk Semi Hard

6.30 Fair

18

Belgioioso Parmesan

BelGioioso Parmesan is a hard, granular cow’s-milk cheese made by BelGioioso Cheese in Wisconsin. The producer states th...

American Branded Hard Cow Milk

6.26 Fair

19

Leerdammer Original

Leerdammer Original is a Dutch semi-hard cow's-milk cheese recognized by its mild flavor, elastic texture, and large int...

Dutch Branded Swiss Style Cow Milk

5.43 Mediocre

20

Mainland Aged Cheddar

Mainland Aged Cheddar is a New Zealand cheddar sold under the Mainland brand, which is owned by Fonterra. The cheese is...

New Zealand Branded Cheddar Hard

5.34 Mediocre