search
Get Started
search

Best Payroll Service

Filter by Tags

Rankings use category fit, feature coverage, pricing signals, public reception, and recency. Affiliate relationships do not affect scores.

0.0 - 10.0

Compare the leading options

See the closest-ranked results side by side before choosing.

Best 1 OnPay
OnPay

OnPay is an online payroll service that automates the processing of employee wages, including calculating taxes, generating paychecks, and providing reporting for small businesses with typically up to 50 employees.

9.08 Excellent
Why this score

Expert favorite with excellent user ratings, transparent pricing, strong tax handling, and responsive support; integrations and advanced HR depth remain limited.

Scoring methodology
2 Justworks
Justworks

Justworks is a fully managed HR platform that handles payroll, benefits administration, and compliance for small businesses with fewer than 100 employees, streamlining HR processes and reducing administrative burdens.

8.91 Great
Why this score

Excellent aggregate ratings for intuitive payroll, benefits, transparent pricing, and responsive support; costly for firms needing payroll alone.

Scoring methodology
3 Patriot Software Payroll

Patriot Software Payroll is a cloud-based solution designed to automate and manage employee compensation processing, including tax calculations, direct deposit, and reporting for businesses of various sizes.

8.76 Great
Why this score

Consistently acclaimed for affordability, unlimited payrolls, usability, and helpful support; fewer advanced HR capabilities and limited administrator mobile functionality.

Scoring methodology
4 Multiplier
Multiplier

Multiplier is an automated payroll platform designed for small and medium-sized businesses, streamlining processes like tax calculations, direct deposit, and reporting to ensure accurate and timely employee payments.

8.66 Great
Why this score

Excellent aggregate ratings praise usability, responsive support, global hiring, and compliance; reporting customization and occasional delayed payouts remain notable weaknesses.

Scoring methodology
5 Gusto for Contractors

While Gusto is known for W-2 employees, its specialized contractor management tools are crucial for the modern gig economy. This specific functionality helps businesses correctly issue 1099 forms, track contractor payments, and manage the unique tax implications associated with non-employee workers,...

6 Remote
Remote

Remote Payroll automates and manages employee payments, tax filings, and reporting for businesses, streamlining the payroll process and reducing administrative burdens through secure online access.

8.42 Great
Why this score

Highly regarded global coverage, compliance tools, and usability; premium pricing and occasionally slow, scripted support reduce consensus enthusiasm.

Scoring methodology
7 Fingercheck

Fingercheck is a cloud-based payroll service designed for small businesses and self-employed individuals, offering features like automated tax calculations, direct deposit payments, and comprehensive reporting to streamline HR processes and ensure accurate wage disbursement.

8.31 Great
Why this score

High user ratings recognize integrated payroll, time tracking, scheduling, and responsive support; setup complexity, mobile issues, and reporting limitations recur.

Scoring methodology
8 APS Payroll

APS Payroll is a cloud-based service offering comprehensive payroll processing for businesses, handling federal and state tax calculations, direct deposit, reporting, and compliance features to streamline payment management.

8.24 Great
Why this score

Strong user satisfaction for payroll accuracy, reporting, implementation support, and unified HR tools; interface complexity and limited small-business suitability prevent top-tier status.

Scoring methodology
9 Zoho Payroll

Zoho Payroll is a cloud-based service that automates payroll processing for businesses, calculating taxes, generating paychecks, and providing reporting features to streamline HR operations and ensure compliance with federal and state regulations.

8.18 Great
Why this score

Strong value, automation, customization, and excellent Zoho ecosystem integration; geographic availability, outside integrations, and direct support are comparatively limited.

Scoring methodology
10 Homebase Payroll

Homebase Payroll is a service integrated into the Homebase employee scheduling and time-tracking platform, aimed at small to medium-sized businesses with hourly workforces. It automates the processing of employee paychecks by calculating wages, taxes, and deductions based on logged hours. The softwa...

8.12 Great
Why this score

Strong choice for hourly teams, combining scheduling, timekeeping, and mobile payroll; limited advanced HR depth and occasional support or synchronization issues remain.

Scoring methodology
11 Oyster
Oyster

Oyster is an automated payroll platform designed for small and medium-sized businesses, streamlining processes like calculating wages, generating paychecks, and managing tax filings directly from employee time tracking data.

8.05 Great
Why this score

Well-regarded global employment platform with intuitive onboarding and strong compliance coverage; pricing, limited payroll flexibility, and support responsiveness are recurring weaknesses.

Scoring methodology
12 Papaya Global

Papaya Global provides global payroll processing and HR solutions, handling multi-country payments, tax compliance, and reporting for multinational businesses with employees worldwide. They focus on streamlining international compensation management for organizations operating across diverse geograp...

7.94 Good
Why this score

Broad multinational payroll coverage, consolidated reporting, and compliance expertise; high pricing, complex onboarding, payment delays, and inconsistent support receive criticism.

Scoring methodology
13 BambooHR (Payroll Add-on)

While BambooHR is the primary HRIS, its integrated payroll add-on is highly valued for its seamless data flow. It allows users to manage employee records and then trigger payroll calculations within the same, familiar interface. This tight coupling minimizes data entry errors and ensures that change...

14 RUN Powered by ADP

RUN Powered by ADP provides automated payroll processing for businesses, handling federal and state tax calculations, direct deposit payments, and reporting to ensure accurate and timely employee compensation disbursements.

7.82 Good
Why this score

Strong brand, dependable tax filing, and broad features; reviewers frequently criticize opaque pricing, add-on fees, and uneven support.

Scoring methodology
15 Roll by ADP

Roll by ADP is an automated payroll processing system that calculates and distributes employee paychecks, manages tax filings, and generates reports for businesses of various sizes, streamlining HR administrative tasks.

7.74 Good
Why this score

Convenient mobile-first payroll with simple conversational workflows and ADP tax infrastructure; limited scalability, integrations, reporting, and occasional payment-timing complaints.

Scoring methodology
16 SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll

SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll automates and manages employee compensation processing, including calculating wages, taxes, deductions, and generating paychecks for organizations globally, integrating with HR data for streamlined payroll operations.

7.72 Good
Why this score

Enterprise-grade global payroll with extensive localization and SAP integration; reviewers cite difficult implementation, dated workflows, complexity, and expensive specialist dependence.

Scoring methodology
17 Wagepoint
Wagepoint

Wagepoint is an automated payroll service designed for small to medium-sized businesses, offering features like tax calculation, direct deposit, and reporting to streamline employee compensation management and reduce administrative burden.

7.63 Good
Why this score

Praised for approachable Canadian payroll, usability, and historically strong support; recent pricing, migration, reliability, and security complaints temper ratings.

Scoring methodology
18 Insperity
Insperity

Insperity provides comprehensive HR solutions for businesses, including payroll processing, benefits administration, and compliance services, catering to companies primarily within the staffing and office products industries.

7.58 Good
Why this score

Respected full-service PEO with knowledgeable specialists and strong compliance support; expensive contracts, dated interfaces, and inconsistent service draw criticism.

Scoring methodology
19 UKG Ready
UKG Ready

UKG (Ultimate Kronos Group) is a powerhouse in workforce management, particularly known for its sophisticated time and attendance tracking. If your business relies heavily on complex shift scheduling, overtime rules, or union rules, UKG provides the granular control necessary to ensure payroll calcu...

20 Oracle Payroll

Oracle Payroll is a comprehensive cloud-based solution offering automated processing of employee paychecks, tax filings, and benefits administration for organizations of various sizes, integrating with broader Oracle business applications.

7.36 Good
Why this score

Powerful, scalable enterprise payroll with deep configurability and global capabilities; costly implementation, steep learning curve, and administrative complexity limit satisfaction.

Scoring methodology
21 ADP TotalSource

ADP TotalSource is a long-standing, reliable payroll processing solution, often favored by businesses that need comprehensive, hands-off payroll management without adopting a full, modern HRIS suite. It is a dependable choice for compliance-heavy payroll needs, particularly for businesses that prefe...

22 Paycor
Paycor

Paycor is a cloud-based human capital management (HCM) platform offering comprehensive payroll processing, time & attendance tracking, and HR functionalities for businesses of various sizes, streamlining workforce management operations.

7.12 Good
Why this score

Broad payroll and HCM functionality suits growing employers; consensus is weakened by implementation friction, support complaints, pricing opacity, and interface complexity.

Scoring methodology
23 SurePayroll

SurePayroll is an online payroll service that automates the processing of employee wages, taxes, and deductions for businesses, offering features like direct deposit and reporting capabilities to simplify compliance.

6.83 Fair
Why this score

Affordable, established small-business payroll with solid tax automation; mixed customer ratings cite withholding errors, support delays, and dated usability.

Scoring methodology
24 Paycraft
Paycraft

Paycraft focuses on providing highly specialized payroll solutions for specific, often regulated, niche industries. If your business falls into a sector with unique pay rules (e.g., unionized labor, specific government contractors), Paycraft's deep industry knowledge can be invaluable. It prioritize...

25 ADP Vantage HCM

ADP Vantage HCM is a cloud-based human capital management system offering comprehensive payroll processing, benefits administration, and workforce analytics for businesses of various sizes, streamlining HR operations and ensuring accurate employee compensation.

6.72 Fair
Why this score

Comprehensive payroll and workforce administration backed by ADP expertise; dated design, cumbersome workflows, opaque pricing, and variable support weaken user sentiment.

Scoring methodology
26 Microsoft Dynamics 365 Payroll

For organizations deeply embedded in the Microsoft ecosystem (using Azure, Teams, etc.), Dynamics 365 offers native integration. It provides a highly structured, enterprise-grade solution that scales with massive global operations, leveraging Microsoft's existing enterprise client base for deploymen...

27 Wave Payroll

Wave Payroll is an integrated accounting and payroll solution designed for small businesses and nonprofits, offering features like automated tax calculations, direct deposit, and reporting to simplify payment processing and compliance.

6.57 Fair
Why this score

Convenient accounting integration, easy setup, and reasonable core ratings; serious support, tax-filing, reliability, and data-handling complaints substantially reduce confidence.

Scoring methodology
28 Heartland Payroll

Heartland Payroll is a financial services company specializing in providing payroll processing solutions to businesses, offering features like direct deposit, tax filing assistance, and reporting capabilities for employers.

6.34 Fair
Why this score

Capable integrated payroll and time management for smaller employers; middling reputation reflects dated workflows, limited transparency, and recurring customer-service frustrations.

Scoring methodology
29 Deluxe Payroll

Deluxe Payroll offers comprehensive payroll processing services for businesses, including federal and state tax calculations, direct deposit payments, and customizable reporting features to streamline HR operations and ensure accurate compliance.

6.18 Fair
Why this score

Established full-service processing with dependable basic payroll and tax capabilities; limited independent acclaim, dated technology, pricing opacity, and support inconsistency constrain ratings.

Scoring methodology
You've reached the end — 29 items

Frequently Asked Questions

Which payroll service leads this ranking?

Lunoo's current ranking places OnPay first with a displayed score of 9.08/10. That is the result of Lunoo's scoring model, not a claim that one choice is best for every person.

How should I read the score and confidence label?

The 0 to 10 score is Lunoo's ranking judgment. Strong confidence means 10 or more recorded comparison checks, some means 2 to 9, and provisional means fewer than 2.

What supports this ranking?

Lunoo combines category fit, feature coverage, pricing and value signals, public reception, recency, and peer comparisons. Public source links support factual item details when available, but they are not required for membership in this 29-item ranking.

Can I compare the leading payroll service?

Yes. The comparison links put adjacent leaders side by side so you can inspect differences that one ranking score cannot capture.

Save to your list

Save your favorites and follow how their scores change over time.

Save favorites
Track changes
Compare scores

Already have an account? Sign in

Compare Items

See how they stack up against each other

Comparing
VS
Select 1 more item to compare