Horror Movies Like Shutter Island

One Hour Photo

90% match · Drama, Mystery

8.15 Great

Dead Ringers

89% match · Mystery, Psychological Horror

8.71 Great

Lost Highway

89% match · Crime, Mystery

8.25 Great

Misery

89% match · Crime, Mystery

8.76 Great

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

89% match · Crime, Mystery

8.17 Great

Inland Empire

88% match · Mystery, Neo Noir

8.42 Great

Memento

87% match · Crime, Mystery

9.30 Excellent

Suspiria

78% match · Crime, Mystery

8.97 Great

The Witch

78% match · Mystery, Psychological Horror

9.02 Excellent

From Hell

78% match · Crime, Mystery

7.47 Good

Christine

78% match · Drama, Mystery

7.96 Good

Glass

78% match · Drama, Mystery

7.08 Good

Invasion of the Body Snatchers

78% match · Drama, Mystery

9.21 Excellent

Angel Heart

78% match · Mystery, Neo Noir

8.31 Great

The Bone Collector

78% match · Drama, Psychological Thriller

7.36 Good

Blood and Black Lace

77% match · Crime, Mystery

8.80 Great

Weapons

77% match · Mystery, Psychological Horror

8.60 Great

Wait Until Dark

77% match · Crime, Psychological Thriller

8.86 Great

The Others

77% match · Mystery, Psychological Horror

8.63 Great

Blood Simple

76% match · Crime, Neo Noir

9.04 Excellent

Carrie

76% match · Psychological Horror, Psychological Thriller

9.10 Excellent

Blue Velvet

76% match · Crime, Mystery

9.01 Excellent

Perfume: The Story of a Murderer

76% match · Crime, Psychological Thriller

8.02 Great

The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog

76% match · Crime, Mystery

8.99 Great