Best Amateur Sleuth

Updated Daily emoji_events View Best Amateur Sleuth Rankings
inventory_2 34 items
trending_up Scored across 12 criteria

Rankings are calculated based on verified user reviews, recency of updates, and community voting weighted by user reputation score.

Filter by Tags
0.0 10.0
Best 1 M.C. Beaton's 'Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death'
M.C. Beaton's 'Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death'

This is the first installment in the Agatha Raisin series, known for its humor and lighthearted approach to mystery. Agatha, a former PR executive, retires to the Cotswolds and finds herself embroiled...

8.8 Very Good
Visit
2 Rhys Bowen's Molly Murphy Series
Rhys Bowen's Molly Murphy Series

Rhys Bowen's Molly Murphy series transports readers to early 20th-century New York City, following the adventures of a spirited Irish immigrant who becomes an accidental detective. Molly's sharp wit a...

8.8 Very Good
Visit
3 Laura Childs' Tea Shop Mysteries
Laura Childs' Tea Shop Mysteries

Laura Childs' Tea Shop Mysteries immerse readers in the delightful world of Charleston, South Carolina, where Theodosia Browning, a tea shop owner, finds herself solving mysteries. Theodosia's passion...

8.7 Very Good
Visit
4 Joanne Fluke's Hannah Swensen Mysteries
Joanne Fluke's Hannah Swensen Mysteries

Joanne Fluke's Hannah Swensen Mysteries follow the adventures of a baker in Lake Eden, Minnesota, who finds herself embroiled in a series of puzzling crimes. Hannah's delicious baked goods and her sha...

8.6 Very Good
Visit
5 Laura Childs' 'Tea Shop Mystery: Death by Darjeeling'
Laura Childs' 'Tea Shop Mystery: Death by Darjeeling'

The first in the Tea Shop Mystery series, this book follows Theodosia Browning, who inherits a tea shop in Charleston, South Carolina, and finds herself investigating a murder. Childs writing is warm...

8.5 Very Good
Visit
6 Joanne Fluke's 'Dinner and Death'
Joanne Fluke's 'Dinner and Death'

The first book in the Hannah Swensen series, 'Dinner and Death,' combines a cozy mystery with delicious recipes. Hannah, a baker in Lake Eden, Minnesota, finds herself investigating a murder after a l...

8.5 Very Good
Visit
7
DE
Death by Chocolate - Terry Lovullo

Terry Lovullo's 'Death by Chocolate' introduces Sue Wellington, a baker who finds herself embroiled in a murder investigation after a customer dies from eating her chocolate cake. The series is known...

8.4 Very Good
Visit
8 Diane Mott Davidson's 'A Deadly Breakfast'
Diane Mott Davidson's 'A Deadly Breakfast'

This is the first book in the Goldy Schulz series, featuring a caterer who finds herself investigating murders in Aspen Meadows, Colorado. Davidsons writing is straightforward and the mysteries are we...

8.3 Very Good
Visit
9 Diane Mott Davidson's Goldy Schulz Series
Diane Mott Davidson's Goldy Schulz Series

Diane Mott Davidson's Goldy Schulz series introduces readers to a caterer in Colorado who finds herself solving mysteries within her close-knit community. Goldy's culinary skills and her keen observat...

8.3 Very Good
Visit
10 The Lemon Orchard Mystery - Joanne Fluke
The Lemon Orchard Mystery - Joanne Fluke

Joanne Fluke's 'The Lemon Orchard Mystery' is the first in a series featuring Hannah Swensen, a baker who solves crimes in her small Minnesota town. The series combines mystery with delicious recipes,...

8.1 Very Good
Visit
11 Ellery Adams' 'Secret Chickens'
Ellery Adams' 'Secret Chickens'

The first in the Edelweiss Mystery series, this book introduces a woman who inherits a chicken farm and discovers a murder. Adams writing is engaging and the characters are well-developed. The unusual...

8.1 Very Good
Visit
12 Sherryl Woods' 'A Vintage Murder'
Sherryl Woods' 'A Vintage Murder'

The first book in the Christy Miller series, this mystery is set in a charming antique shop in a small town. Christy, the shop owner, discovers a hidden secret and a murder. Woods writing is accessibl...

8.1 Very Good
Visit
13 Janis Patterson's 'Whiskey Beach Murders'
Janis Patterson's 'Whiskey Beach Murders'

The first in the Dixie Montgomery series, this book introduces a former New York City detective who retires to a small town in North Carolina and finds herself drawn into a murder investigation. Patte...

8.1 Very Good
Visit
14 Katherine Reay's The Beach House Mysteries
Katherine Reay's The Beach House Mysteries

Katherine Reay's The Beach House Mysteries follow the adventures of a young woman who inherits a beach house and finds herself solving mysteries within her new community. The series combines engaging...

8.0 Very Good
Visit
15 Murder on Black Swan Lake - Elizabeth Peters
Murder on Black Swan Lake - Elizabeth Peters

Elizabeth Peters' 'Murder on Black Swan Lake' is a delightful blend of mystery and theatrical intrigue. Set in the world of ballet, the story follows Amelia Peabody's niece as she investigates a murde...

7.9 Good
Visit
16 Victoria Hamilton's 'Death by Darjeeling'
Victoria Hamilton's 'Death by Darjeeling'

This is the first book in the Mystery at the Tea Shop series, featuring Kira Harding, who inherits a tea shop in a quaint English village and finds herself investigating a murder. Hamiltons writing is...

7.9 Good
Visit
17 Ellery Adams' Secret, Book, and Scone Society Mysteries
Ellery Adams' Secret, Book, and Scone Society Mysteries

Ellery Adams' Secret, Book, and Scone Society Mysteries introduce readers to a group of friends who run a bookstore in a charming small town and find themselves solving mysteries together. The series...

7.9 Good
Visit
18 Sheila Riley's 'Murder on Sugar Maple Lane'
Sheila Riley's 'Murder on Sugar Maple Lane'

The first in the Farmer & Me Mystery series, this book introduces a woman who moves to a small town in New England and finds herself investigating a murder. Rileys writing is straightforward and the c...

7.8 Good
Visit
19 Laura Lippman's Tess Monaghan Series
Laura Lippman's Tess Monaghan Series

Laura Lippman's Tess Monaghan series follows the adventures of a Baltimore-based private investigator who finds herself entangled in a series of complex and intriguing cases. Tess's sharp wit and dete...

7.8 Good
Visit
20
RO
Rosemary and Rue - Laura Childs

Laura Childs' 'Rosemary and Rue' introduces Megan Dashwood, a tea shop owner who finds herself investigating a murder in Charleston, South Carolina. The series is known for its charming setting, quirk...

7.7 Good
Visit
21 Jenn McKinlay's 'Cupcakes and Cashmere'
Jenn McKinlay's 'Cupcakes and Cashmere'

The first in the Hat Shop Mystery series, this book follows a woman who inherits a hat shop and finds herself investigating a murder. McKinlays writing is lighthearted and the characters are quirky. T...

7.7 Good
Visit
22 Anne George's A Curious Beginning
Anne George's A Curious Beginning

Anne George's A Curious Beginning introduces readers to Charlotte Gold, a retired English teacher who finds herself solving mysteries in her Florida community. Charlotte's sharp wit and keen observati...

7.7 Good
23 Victoria Hamilton's Aunt Dimity Series
Victoria Hamilton's Aunt Dimity Series

Victoria Hamilton's Aunt Dimity series follows the adventures of a young woman who discovers a hidden aunt and a series of clues that lead her on a journey of self-discovery and mystery-solving. The s...

7.7 Good
Visit
24 The Beekeeper's Apprentice - Laurie R. King
The Beekeeper's Apprentice - Laurie R. King

Laurie R. King's 'The Beekeeper's Apprentice' is a unique and engaging mystery set in the 1920s, featuring a young woman who learns the art of deduction from a brilliant but eccentric beekeeper. The b...

7.6 Good
Visit
25
TH
The Patchwork Puzzler - Leslie Meier

Leslie Meier's 'The Patchwork Puzzler' introduces Penny Farmer, a quilter who finds herself solving mysteries in her small Connecticut town. The series is known for its charming setting, quirky charac...

7.5 Good
Visit
26 Richard Osman's 'The Thursday Murder Club'
Richard Osman's 'The Thursday Murder Club'

This book introduces a group of retirees who meet weekly to discuss unsolved crimes and find themselves investigating a real murder. Osmans writing is witty and the characters are quirky. The retireme...

7.5 Good
Visit
27 Mary Higgins Clark's 'A Pocket Full of Murder'
Mary Higgins Clark's 'A Pocket Full of Murder'

This is the first book in the Olsen & Claire series, featuring a fashion editor who finds herself investigating a murder. Clarks writing is suspenseful and the characters are well-developed. The vinta...

7.5 Good
Visit
28 The Hollow Tree - Elizabeth S. Craig
The Hollow Tree - Elizabeth S. Craig

Elizabeth S. Craig's 'The Hollow Tree' is a historical cozy mystery set in the 1880s, featuring April Pitt and her husband as they investigate a series of unsettling events in their new Ohio town. The...

7.4 Good
Visit
29 Katherine Reay's 'The Inheritance'
Katherine Reay's 'The Inheritance'

This book follows a woman who discovers a hidden manuscript and finds herself investigating a mystery surrounding its author. Reays writing is elegant and the characters are well-developed. The litera...

7.4 Good
Visit
30 Jenn McKinlay's Hat Shop Mysteries
Jenn McKinlay's Hat Shop Mysteries

Jenn McKinlay's Hat Shop Mysteries follow the adventures of a woman who inherits a hat shop and finds herself solving mysteries in her new community. The series combines engaging characters, clever pl...

7.4 Good
Visit
Loading more...

Save to your list

Create your first list and start tracking the tools that matter to you.

Track favorites
Get updates
Compare scores

Already have an account? Sign in

Compare Items

See how they stack up against each other

Comparing
VS
Select 1 more item to compare