swap_horiz Cotija Alternatives

1

Gruyère AOP

Made from raw cow's milk, Gruyère AOP belongs to Switzerland's tradition of firm, cooked-curd cheeses. Its name connects...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.20 Excellent

2

L'Etivaz AOP

Wood-fired copper cauldrons are central to the identity of L'Etivaz AOP, a Swiss hard cheese made in alpine chalets in t...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.20 Excellent

3

Comté AOP

Raw cow's milk and a cooked, pressed curd define Comté AOP, a hard cheese from the French Jura Massif. Local dairies tra...

French Alpine Aop Aged

9.20 Excellent

4

Beaufort AOP

A concave outer edge identifies the wheels of Beaufort AOP, a raw cow's milk cheese from Savoie in the French Alps. This...

Alpine Aop Aged Cow Milk

9.20 Excellent

5

Pleasant Ridge Reserve

From its farm in Wisconsin, Uplands Cheese Company makes Pleasant Ridge Reserve as an aged cheese inspired by European a...

Artisan Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

9.20 Excellent

6

Westcombe Cheddar

Westcombe Cheddar is a hard cheese crafted by Westcombe Dairy in Somerset, England. It utilizes unpasteurized cow’s milk...

Artisan Somerset Aged Cow Milk

9.05 Excellent

7

Grana Padano Riserva

Grana Padano Riserva is a traditional Italian hard cheese produced in the Po Valley. It undergoes a rigorous aging proce...

Italian Aged Dop Cow Milk

8.95 Great

8

Parmigiano Reggiano

Parmigiano Reggiano is a traditional Italian hard cheese produced exclusively within a designated area of Northern Italy...

Italian Dop Hard Cow Milk

8.79 Great

9

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar is a hard cheese produced by Bwlchwernen Fawr farm in Ceredigion. It utilizes cow milk from...

Organic Artisan Welsh Aged

8.75 Great

10

Berner Alpkäse AOP

Berner Alpkäse AOP is a distinctive Swiss hard cheese crafted using raw cow’s milk from alpine herds within the canton o...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

8.65 Great

11

Beemster Classic

The Beemster Classic is a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted using cow’s milk sourced from farms within the Beemster...

Brand Aged Dutch Butterscotch

8.65 Great

12

Appenzeller

Appenzeller is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from raw cow’s milk. It originates in the Appenzell region and is...

Swiss Artisan Aged Cow Milk

8.55 Great

13

Queijo São Jorge DOP

Queijo São Jorge DOP is a traditional hard cheese originating on the Azorean island of São Jorge. Made from raw cow’s mi...

Aged Dop Sharp Cow Milk

8.55 Great

14

Quicke's Mature Cheddar

Quicke’s Mature Cheddar is an artisan hard cheese crafted by the Quicke family in Devon. The cheese utilizes cow's milk...

Artisan Aged Devonian Cow Milk

8.55 Great

15

Sbrinz AOP

Sbrinz AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from raw cow’s milk primarily sourced in the canton of Lucerne. Re...

Swiss Dop Hard Cow Milk

8.51 Great

16

Trentingrana

Trentingrana is a traditional Italian hard cheese crafted from cow’s milk sourced solely within the Trentino region of t...

Aged Dop Trentino Cow Milk

8.20 Great

17

SarVecchio Parmesan

SarVecchio Parmesan is a hard cheese crafted by the Sartori Company of Wisconsin. It’s notable for its extended aging pr...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.20 Great

18

Dry Jack (Vella Cheese Co.)

Dry Jack is an American hard cheese produced by the Vella Cheese Company, based in Sonoma, California. It was originally...

Artisan Aged Californian Cow Milk

7.80 Good

19

Cotija Añejo

Cotija Añejo is the aged form of Cotija, a Mexican cheese named after Cotija de la Paz in Michoacán. It is generally a f...

Traditional Mexican Hard Cow Milk

6.44 Fair

20

Queso Añejo

Queso añejo is a firm, aged Mexican cheese whose name means old cheese. It is traditionally made from skimmed goat's mil...

Aged Mexican Firm Cow Milk

6.35 Fair