Ice Creams Like Klondike Reese's Bar

Magnum Almond Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

8.34 Great

Magnum Classic Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

8.16 Great

Magnum Double Caramel Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

7.92 Good

Klondike Original Bar

Ice Cream

7.86 Good

Klondike Oreo Sandwich

Ice Cream

7.18 Good

Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup

Ice Cream

8.34 Great

Dove Silky Smooth Vanilla Bar

Ice Cream

7.92 Good

Magnum Double Chocolate Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

7.86 Good

Baskin-Robbins Reese's Peanut Butter Cup

Ice Cream

7.86 Good

Talenti Peanut Butter Fudge Gelato

Ice Cream

7.74 Good

Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake Bar

Ice Cream

7.70 Good

Magnum White Chocolate Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

7.42 Good

Dairy Queen Dilly Bar

Ice Cream

7.42 Good

Cornetto Classic

Ice Cream

7.38 Good

Walls Twister

Ice Cream

7.34 Good

Good Humor Toasted Almond Bar

Ice Cream

7.28 Good

Good Humor Chocolate Éclair Bar

Ice Cream

7.24 Good

Walls Feast

Ice Cream

7.20 Good

Klondike Dark Chocolate Bar

Ice Cream

7.05 Good

Kit Kat Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

7.02 Good

Walls Calippo Lemon

Ice Cream

6.88 Fair

Magnum Ruby Ice Cream Bar

Ice Cream

6.78 Fair

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Ice Cream

9.18 Excellent

Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia

Ice Cream

9.05 Excellent