swap_horiz Armstrong Cheddar Alternatives

1

Gruyère AOP

Gruyère AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from cow’s milk within the Gruyères region of Fribourg. Recognize...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

2

L'Etivaz AOP

L'Etivaz AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted within the Vaud Pre-Alps. Production occurs in alpine chalets be...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

3

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère is a traditional Swiss cheese crafted from cow’s milk and aged within the natural sandstone c...

Swiss Brand Nutty Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

4

Comté AOP

Comté AOP is a hard cheese produced in the French Jura Massif region. It’s notable for being France's largest protected...

French Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

5

Beaufort AOP

Beaufort AOP is a traditional French hard cheese originating in the Savoie region of the Alps. It’s produced using raw c...

Alpine Aop Aged Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

6

Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an aged, hard cheese produced by Uplands Cheese Company in Wisconsin. It’s notable for being t...

Artisan Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

7

Westcombe Cheddar

Westcombe Cheddar is a hard cheese crafted by Westcombe Dairy in Somerset, England. It utilizes unpasteurized cow’s milk...

Artisan Somerset Aged Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

8

Grana Padano Riserva

Grana Padano Riserva is a traditional Italian hard cheese produced in the Po Valley. It undergoes a rigorous aging proce...

Italian Aged Dop Cow Milk

9.0 Excellent

9

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar is a hard cheese produced by Bwlchwernen Fawr farm in Ceredigion. It utilizes cow milk from...

Organic Artisan Welsh Aged

8.8 Great

10

Reypenaer VSOP

Reypenaer VSOP is a complex Dutch hard cheese crafted primarily from cow’s milk. The brand, steeped in tradition, ages i...

Complex Brand Dutch Cow Milk

8.8 Great

11

Beemster Classic

The Beemster Classic is a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted using cow’s milk sourced from farms within the Beemster...

Brand Aged Dutch Butterscotch

8.7 Great

12

Queijo São Jorge DOP

Queijo São Jorge DOP is a traditional hard cheese originating on the Azorean island of São Jorge. Made from raw cow’s mi...

Aged Dop Sharp Cow Milk

8.6 Great

13

Roth Grand Cru

Roth Grand Cru is an aged Wisconsin cow’s milk hard cheese inspired by traditional Alpine Gruyère production methods. It...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.4 Great

14

SarVecchio Parmesan

SarVecchio Parmesan is a hard cheese crafted by the Sartori Company of Wisconsin. It’s notable for its extended aging pr...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.2 Great

15

Prima Donna

Prima Donna is a branded Dutch cow's-milk cheese produced in the style of a firm, matured Gouda while drawing comparison...

Brand Aged Dutch Cow Milk

7.9 Good

16

Grafton Village Cheddar

Grafton Village Cheddar is an American cow's milk cheddar produced by Grafton Village Cheese Company in Vermont, whose o...

Artisan Aged Sharp Vermont

7.9 Good

17

BellaVitano

BellaVitano is a cow's-milk cheese produced in Wisconsin by Sartori, an American family-owned cheesemaker. It is an aged...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.9 Good

18

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano is a Wisconsin cow's milk cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, hand-rubbed with Merlot wi...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.8 Good

19

Balderson Cheddar

Balderson Cheddar is a Canadian cheese brand associated with the community of Balderson in Ontario. Its products are mad...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

6.9 Fair

20

Black Diamond Cheddar

Black Diamond Cheddar is a Canadian cheese brand associated with Parmalat Canada. Its products include cheddar made from...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

6.0 Fair