swap_horiz Mellow Mushroom Alternatives

1

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, established in 1964, operates with a coal-fired brick oven and utilizes a traditional Neapolitan do...

Premium Regional Dine In Ny Style

7.8 Good

2

Jet's Pizza

Founded in Detroit in 1946, Jet’s Pizza is renowned for its deep-dish style pizza featuring a thick, crispy crust, gener...

Delivery Midwest Chain Deep Dish

7.6 Good

3

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza originated in Detroit, Michigan, utilizing a custom-built oven that burns hotter than convent...

Premium Northeast Dine In Coal Fired

7.2 Good

4

Patxi's Pizza

Patxi’s Pizza, originating in Detroit, Michigan, is known for its deep-dish rectangular pizza featuring a thick, buttery...

Premium West Coast Deep Dish Dine In

7.0 Good

5

Marco's Pizza

Founded in Detroit in 1967, Marco’s Pizza is known for its deep-dish rectangular pizzas featuring a thick, hand-tossed c...

Delivery Italian National Chain

6.9 Fair

6

Round Table Pizza

Round Table Pizza, founded in Detroit in 1957, is known for its distinctive “Detroit Style” pizza featuring a rectangula...

Premium Family West Coast Chain

6.7 Fair

7

Donatos Pizza

Donato’s Pizza, established in Detroit in 1978, is known for its rectangular deep-dish pizzas featuring a thick, crispy...

Delivery Midwest Edge To Edge Thin Crust

6.7 Fair

8

MOD Pizza

MOD Pizza is a Detroit-based chain offering customizable pizzas built on a proprietary dough base where customers select...

Modern Fast Casual Chain Individual

6.6 Fair

9

Domino's Pizza

Domino's Pizza is an American restaurant company and pizza chain that began with one location in Ypsilanti, Michigan, in...

Delivery Value Global Fast Food

6.4 Fair

10

Mountain Mike's Pizza

Mountain Mike’s Pizza, originating in Michigan, is known for its deep-dish pizzas featuring a thick, spongy crust and ge...

Family West Coast Chain Dine In

6.4 Fair

11

Screamin' Sicilian Pizza Co.

Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza Co. specializes in thick, rectangular pizzas topped with a generous layer of tomato sauce, mozz...

Premium Retail Craft Frozen

6.3 Fair

12

Hungry Howie's

Hungry Howie’s Pizza is known for its Detroit-style pizza featuring a thick, rectangular crust pressed into cupped edges...

Delivery Value Midwest Chain

6.2 Fair

13

Bertucci's

Bertucci’s Motor City Pizza is known for its distinctive square Detroit-style pizza featuring a thick, focaccia-like cru...

Italian Casual Northeast Dine In

6.2 Fair

14

Papa Murphy's

Papa Murphy’s is a chain of take-and-bake frozen pizza kits that customers purchase and complete the final baking proces...

Value National Fresh Chain

6.1 Fair

15

Your Pie

Your Pie is a Detroit-style pizza chain known for its rectangular pies with a thick, crispy crust and generous applicati...

Modern Fast Casual Southern Build Your Own

6.1 Fair

16

Pizza Ranch

Pizza Ranch is a Detroit-style pizza chain known for its large, rectangular pizzas with a thick, airy crust and generous...

Family Midwest Chain Buffet

6.1 Fair

17

Pizza Hut

Founded in 1958 by brothers Dan and Frank Carney in Wichita, Kansas, Pizza Hut grew from a single restaurant into the wo...

Global Fast Food Chain Dine In

5.9 Mediocre

18

Happy Joe's

Happy Joe’s Pizza, originating in Detroit, Michigan, is known for its distinctive “Crazy Jerry” pizza featuring a thick,...

Family Midwest Chain Dine In

5.8 Mediocre

19

Godfather's Pizza

Founded in Detroit in 1967, Godfather’s Pizza is known for its deep-dish pizza style, utilizing a thick, hand-tossed cru...

Legacy Midwest Chain Dine In

5.7 Mediocre

20

Shakey's Pizza

Shakey’s Pizza, originating in Ann Arbor, Michigan in 1957, is recognized as a pioneering “motor city pizza” known for i...

Legacy Family Thin Crust Chain

5.7 Mediocre