swap_horiz Cougar Gold Alternatives

1

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an American artisan hard cheese crafted using alpine-style techniques. Produced by Upl...

American Artisan Hard Cow Milk

9.4 Excellent

2

Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an aged, hard cheese produced by Uplands Cheese Company in Wisconsin. It’s notable for being t...

Artisan Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

3

Westcombe Cheddar

Westcombe Cheddar is a hard cheese crafted by Westcombe Dairy in Somerset, England. It utilizes unpasteurized cow’s milk...

Artisan Somerset Aged Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

4

Cheddar (Clothbound Cave-Aged)

Clothbound Cave-Aged Cheddar is an American artisan hard cheese produced using a traditional aging method. The cheese un...

American Artisan Sharp Cow Milk

9.0 Excellent

5

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar

Hafod Welsh Organic Cheddar is a hard cheese produced by Bwlchwernen Fawr farm in Ceredigion. It utilizes cow milk from...

Organic Artisan Welsh Aged

8.8 Great

6

Sartori SarVecchio

American hard cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, Wisconsin, aged over 20 months in a Parmesan style, named Best of...

American Aged Hard Cow Milk

8.7 Great

7

Appenzeller

Appenzeller is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from raw cow’s milk. It originates in the Appenzell region and is...

Swiss Artisan Aged Cow Milk

8.6 Great

8

Quicke's Mature Cheddar

Quicke’s Mature Cheddar is an artisan hard cheese crafted by the Quicke family in Devon. The cheese utilizes cow's milk...

Artisan Aged Devonian Cow Milk

8.6 Great

9

Vella Dry Jack

American dry-aged Monterey Jack from Vella Cheese Company in Sonoma, California, aged over seven months with a distincti...

American Aged Hard Cow Milk

8.5 Great

10

Cabot Vintage Choice Cheddar

Aged cheddar from Vermont's Cabot Creamery cooperative, matured at least two years, offering a pronounced sharp flavor p...

American Aged Cheddar Hard

8.1 Great

11

Coolea

Coolea is an artisan hard cheese originating from Coolea, County Cork, Ireland. Produced since the late 1970s by Dick Wi...

Artisan Aged Irish Cow Milk

8.1 Great

12

Beehive Barely Buzzed

Beehive Barely Buzzed is an artisan hard cheese crafted by the Beehive Cheese Company in Utah. The cheese utilizes cow’s...

Utah Artisan Aged Cow Milk

8.1 Great

13

Urner Bergkäse

Urner Bergkäse is a Swiss raw-milk hard cheese from the Canton of Uri, traditionally produced by alpine dairies using mi...

Swiss Mountain Artisan Aged

8.0 Great

14

Hegarty's Cheddar

Hegarty’s Cheddar is a traditional Irish hard cheese crafted by the Hegarty family in County Cork. It utilizes cow's mil...

Traditional Artisan Aged Irish

8.0 Great

15

Provola dei Nebrodi

Provola dei Nebrodi is a stretched-curd semi-hard cheese from the Nebrodi Mountains of Sicily, made from the milk of Sic...

Artisan Aged Sicilian Cow Milk

7.9 Good

16

Grafton Village Cheddar

American cheddar made by Grafton Village Cheese Company in Vermont, a cooperative founded in 1892, known for award-winni...

Artisan Aged Sharp Vermont

7.9 Good

17

Dry Jack (Vella Cheese Co.)

American hard cheese developed by Vella Cheese Company in Sonoma, California, created during World War II as a domestic...

Artisan Aged Californian Cow Milk

7.8 Good

18

Gabriel

Irish hard cheese from West Cork Natural Cheese made with unpasteurized cow's milk, aged over 12 months, and inspired by...

Artisan Aged Irish Cow Milk

7.6 Good

19

Beehive Promontory

Beehive Promontory is an aged cow's milk cheese from Beehive Cheese Company in Uintah, Utah, made from raw milk and know...

Utah Artisan Aged Firm

7.6 Good

20

Point Reyes Toma

Point Reyes Toma is a semi-hard cow's milk cheese made by Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese Company in Marin County, Californ...

Artisan Aged Californian Firm

7.5 Good