swap_horiz Colby (Aged) Alternatives

1

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an American artisan hard cheese crafted using alpine-style techniques. Produced by Upl...

American Artisan Hard Cow Milk

9.4 Excellent

2

Gruyère AOP

Gruyère AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted from cow’s milk within the Gruyères region of Fribourg. Recognize...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

3

L'Etivaz AOP

L'Etivaz AOP is a traditional Swiss hard cheese crafted within the Vaud Pre-Alps. Production occurs in alpine chalets be...

Swiss Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

4

Comté AOP

Comté AOP is a hard cheese produced in the French Jura Massif region. It’s notable for being France's largest protected...

French Alpine Aop Aged

9.2 Excellent

5

Beaufort AOP

Beaufort AOP is a traditional French hard cheese originating in the Savoie region of the Alps. It’s produced using raw c...

Alpine Aop Aged Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

6

Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an aged, hard cheese produced by Uplands Cheese Company in Wisconsin. It’s notable for being t...

Artisan Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

7

Aged Gouda (Old)

Aged Gouda represents a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted from cow’s milk. The extended aging process, typically exc...

Dutch Caramel Snacking Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

8

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar is an American hard cheese crafted through a unique partnership between Cabot Creamery and Jasp...

American Cheddar Hard Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

9

Westcombe Cheddar

Westcombe Cheddar is a hard cheese crafted by Westcombe Dairy in Somerset, England. It utilizes unpasteurized cow’s milk...

Artisan Somerset Aged Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

10

Sartori SarVecchio

American hard cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, Wisconsin, aged over 20 months in a Parmesan style, named Best of...

American Aged Hard Cow Milk

8.7 Great

11

Vella Dry Jack

American dry-aged Monterey Jack from Vella Cheese Company in Sonoma, California, aged over seven months with a distincti...

American Aged Hard Cow Milk

8.5 Great

12

Cabot Vintage Choice Cheddar

Aged cheddar from Vermont's Cabot Creamery cooperative, matured at least two years, offering a pronounced sharp flavor p...

American Aged Cheddar Hard

8.1 Great

13

Mimolette Vieille

Mimolette Vieille is a traditional French hard cheese originating from the Lille region. It’s notable for its distinctiv...

French Aged Nutty Snacking

8.1 Great

14

Cougar Gold

American hard cheese developed at Washington State University in the 1940s and sold in distinctive 30-ounce sealed tin c...

American Artisan Aged Canned

8.0 Great

15

Tillamook Aged White Cheddar

White cheddar from Tillamook County Creamery Association in Oregon, aged at least nine months, one of the Pacific Northw...

American Aged Cheddar Hard

7.4 Good

16

Noord-Hollandse Edammer PDO

Noord-Hollandse Edammer PDO is a Dutch ball-shaped cow's milk cheese from North Holland, protected since 1996 and tradit...

Mild Pdo Aged Dutch

7.4 Good

17

Aged Havarti

Aged Havarti is a Danish cow's milk cheese that, when matured beyond its standard semi-soft stage, develops a firmer tex...

Danish Aged Sharp Snacking

6.9 Fair

18

Svecia

Swedish semi-hard cow's milk cheese with centuries of documented history, produced throughout the country with a mild, t...

Mild Traditional Aged Swedish

6.8 Fair

19

Danbo

Denmark's most consumed cheese, a mild semi-hard cow's milk variety with small irregular holes, sometimes flavored with...

Mild Danish Traditional Aged

6.6 Fair

20

Maribo

Danish semi-hard cow's milk cheese from the island of Lolland, similar to Danbo but with more irregular holes and a slig...

Mild Danish Traditional Aged

6.5 Fair