swap_horiz Midnight Moon Alternatives

1

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère is a traditional Swiss cheese crafted from cow’s milk and aged within the natural sandstone c...

Swiss Brand Nutty Cow Milk

9.2 Excellent

2

Beemster Classic

The Beemster Classic is a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted using cow’s milk sourced from farms within the Beemster...

Brand Aged Dutch Butterscotch

8.7 Great

3

Noord-Hollandse Gouda PDO

Noord-Hollandse Gouda PDO is a hard cheese originating solely within North Holland, Netherlands. Designated as Protected...

Pdo Aged Dutch Nutty

8.5 Great

4

Roth Grand Cru

Roth Grand Cru is an aged Wisconsin cow’s milk hard cheese inspired by traditional Alpine Gruyère production methods. It...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.4 Great

5

Zamorano DOP

Zamorano DOP is a traditional hard cheese produced exclusively in the Spanish province of Zamora. Crafted from sheep’s m...

Aged Dop Nutty Castilian

8.3 Great

6

SarVecchio Parmesan

SarVecchio Parmesan is a hard cheese crafted by the Sartori Company of Wisconsin. It’s notable for its extended aging pr...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.2 Great

7

Mimolette Vieille

Mimolette Vieille is a traditional French hard cheese originating from the Lille region. It’s notable for its distinctiv...

French Aged Nutty Snacking

8.1 Great

8

Ewephoria

Ewephoria is a Dutch hard cheese crafted from sheep’s milk. It gained recognition for its distinctive sweet taste remini...

Brand Aged Dutch Sweet

8.1 Great

9

Garrotxa

Garrotxa is a firm, aged hard-cheese originating in Catalonia, Spain’s Garrotxa region. Traditionally made from goat's m...

Artisan Aged Catalan Firm

8.0 Great

10

Prima Donna

Dutch hard cheese created by Vandersterre, blending Gouda and Parmesan influences and aged 12 or more months to develop...

Brand Aged Dutch Cow Milk

7.9 Good

11

BellaVitano

American hard cheese created by Sartori Company in Plymouth, Wisconsin, with a creamy, flaky texture blending characteri...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.9 Good

12

Aged Crottin de Chavignol

Aged Crottin de Chavignol is a French AOC goat cheese from the Loire Valley village of Chavignol; extended aging produce...

Aop Aged Berry Hard

7.9 Good

13

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano is a Wisconsin cow's milk cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, hand-rubbed with Merlot wi...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.8 Good

14

Roth Prairie Sunset

Roth Prairie Sunset is an American alpine-style cow's milk cheese produced by Roth Cheese in Monroe, Wisconsin, crafted...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.5 Good

15

Petit Basque

Semi-hard French sheep's milk cheese from the Basque region, smaller than Ossau-Iraty at roughly 900 g, with a mild, but...

French Brand Aged Firm

7.2 Good

16

Chimay Vieux

Chimay Vieux is a hard cow's milk cheese produced by Cistercian monks at Scourmont Abbey in Chimay, Belgium, the same co...

Brand Aged Monastery Belgian

7.2 Good

17

Pélardon Affiné

Pélardon Affiné is a French PDO goat cheese from the Languedoc-Roussillon region; when further aged beyond the fresh sta...

Artisan Aged Hard Languedoc

7.1 Good

18

Samsø (Aged)

Danish hard cheese from the island of Samsø, developed in the 19th century under Swiss cheesemaking influence, with a sw...

Danish Traditional Aged Nutty

6.9 Fair

19

Balderson Cheddar

Balderson Cheddar is a Canadian aged cheddar produced in Balderson, Ontario since the 1800s, notable for heritage-grade...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

6.9 Fair

20

Black Diamond Cheddar

Black Diamond Cheddar is a Canadian brand owned by Parmalat Canada, best known for its extra-old cheddar aged up to four...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

6.0 Fair