swap_horiz Midnight Moon Alternatives

1

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère

Kaltbach Cave-Aged Gruyère is a traditional Swiss cheese crafted from cow’s milk and aged within the natural sandstone c...

Swiss Brand Nutty Cow Milk

9.20 Excellent

2

Comté AOP

Raw cow's milk and a cooked, pressed curd define Comté AOP, a hard cheese from the French Jura Massif. Local dairies tra...

French Alpine Aop Aged

9.20 Excellent

3

Pleasant Ridge Reserve

From its farm in Wisconsin, Uplands Cheese Company makes Pleasant Ridge Reserve as an aged cheese inspired by European a...

Artisan Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

9.20 Excellent

4

Beemster Classic

The Beemster Classic is a traditional Dutch hard cheese crafted using cow’s milk sourced from farms within the Beemster...

Brand Aged Dutch Butterscotch

8.65 Great

5

Noord-Hollandse Gouda PDO

Noord-Hollandse Gouda PDO is a hard cheese originating solely within North Holland, Netherlands. Designated as Protected...

Pdo Aged Dutch Nutty

8.45 Great

6

Roth Grand Cru

Roth Grand Cru is an aged Wisconsin cow’s milk hard cheese inspired by traditional Alpine Gruyère production methods. It...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.35 Great

7

Zamorano DOP

Zamorano DOP is a traditional hard cheese produced exclusively in the Spanish province of Zamora. Crafted from sheep’s m...

Aged Dop Nutty Castilian

8.25 Great

8

SarVecchio Parmesan

SarVecchio Parmesan is a hard cheese crafted by the Sartori Company of Wisconsin. It’s notable for its extended aging pr...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.20 Great

9

Mimolette Vieille

Mimolette Vieille is a traditional French hard cheese originating from the Lille region. It’s notable for its distinctiv...

French Aged Nutty Snacking

8.05 Great

10

Ewephoria

Ewephoria is a Dutch hard cheese crafted from sheep’s milk. It gained recognition for its distinctive sweet taste remini...

Brand Aged Dutch Sweet

8.05 Great

11

Garrotxa

Garrotxa is a firm, aged hard-cheese originating in Catalonia, Spain’s Garrotxa region. Traditionally made from goat's m...

Artisan Aged Catalan Firm

8.00 Great

12

Prima Donna

Prima Donna is a branded Dutch cow's-milk cheese produced in the style of a firm, matured Gouda while drawing comparison...

Brand Aged Dutch Cow Milk

7.85 Good

13

BellaVitano

BellaVitano is a cow's-milk cheese produced in Wisconsin by Sartori, an American family-owned cheesemaker. It is an aged...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.85 Good

14

Queso Majorero DOP

Queso Majorero DOP is a firm, aged goat's milk cheese produced on the island of Fuerteventura in the Canary Islands, Spa...

Aged Dop Firm Canarian

7.80 Good

15

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano

Sartori Merlot BellaVitano is a Wisconsin cow's milk cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, hand-rubbed with Merlot wi...

Brand Aged Wisconsin Cow Milk

7.75 Good

16

Queso Ibores DOP

Queso Ibores DOP is a firm, artisanal goat's milk cheese produced in the Extremadura region of western Spain. It is made...

Aged Dop Paprika Goat Milk

7.65 Good

17

Petit Basque

Petit Basque is a French sheep's milk cheese from the Basque Country region of southwestern France. It weighs approximat...

French Brand Aged Firm

7.15 Good

18

Balderson Cheddar

Balderson Cheddar is a Canadian cheese brand associated with the community of Balderson in Ontario. Its products are mad...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

6.85 Fair

19

Black Diamond Cheddar

Black Diamond Cheddar is a Canadian cheese brand associated with Parmalat Canada. Its products include cheddar made from...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

5.95 Mediocre

20

Armstrong Cheddar

Armstrong Cheddar is a Canadian cheddar cheese brand associated with Saputo, a major dairy company. The brand has market...

Brand Canadian Aged Sharp

5.40 Mediocre