Judges Like John Jay

Joseph Story

Judge

8.42 Great

William Howard Taft

Judge

7.59 Good

Edward White

Judge

6.30 Fair

Salmon P. Chase

Judge

5.34 Mediocre

Morrison Waite

Judge

4.74 Poor

Fred Vinson

Judge

3.73 Poor

Samuel Chase

Judge

3.17 Poor

Roger B. Taney

Judge

2.30 Poor

Robert Jackson

Judge

8.69 Great

John Marshall Harlan I

Judge

8.60 Great

John Paul Stevens

Judge

7.96 Good

John Roberts

Judge

7.31 Good

John Marshall Harlan II

Judge

7.18 Good

Harry Blackmun

Judge

6.67 Fair

James Byrnes

Judge

6.26 Fair

George Sutherland

Judge

6.12 Fair

Tom Clark

Judge

5.98 Mediocre

Edward Sanford

Judge

5.89 Mediocre

Joseph Rucker Lamar

Judge

5.80 Mediocre

Stephen Field

Judge

5.70 Mediocre

Horace Gray

Judge

5.66 Mediocre

Mahlon Pitney

Judge

5.61 Mediocre

John H. Clarke

Judge

5.52 Mediocre

David Brewer

Judge

5.15 Mediocre