swap_horiz Vella Dry Jack Alternatives

1

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve

Uplands Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an American artisan hard cheese crafted using alpine-style techniques. Produced by Upl...

American Artisan Hard Cow Milk

9.4 Excellent

2

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar

Cabot Clothbound Cheddar is an American hard cheese crafted through a unique partnership between Cabot Creamery and Jasp...

American Cheddar Hard Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

3

Fiscalini Bandage Wrapped Cheddar

Fiscalini Bandage Wrapped Cheddar is a hard American cheddar produced at Fiscalini Farmstead Cheese. The cheese utilizes...

American Cheddar Hard Cow Milk

9.1 Excellent

4

Sartori SarVecchio

American hard cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, Wisconsin, aged over 20 months in a Parmesan style, named Best of...

American Aged Hard Cow Milk

8.7 Great

5

Lekkerkerker Fermier Oude Kaas

Dutch raw-milk farmhouse aged Gouda from the Lekkerkerker family farm, a fermier cheese ripened to develop complex, cara...

Aged Dutch Hard Cow Milk

8.6 Great

6

Beemster XO

Dutch aged Gouda from North Holland's Beemster polder, aged at least 26 months, developing caramel and butterscotch flav...

Aged Dutch Hard Cow Milk

8.5 Great

7

Mimolette Extra Vieille

Mimolette Extra Vieille is a hard, aged French cow's milk cheese, visually distinguished by its bright orange color and...

French Northern Aged Hard

8.4 Great

8

Hook's 10 Year Cheddar

American aged cheddar from Hook's Cheese Company in Mineral Point, Wisconsin, matured ten years, developing a crystallin...

American Cheddar Hard Cow Milk

8.3 Great

9

Salers

Salers is a robust French cheese made exclusively from raw cow's milk, traditionally produced only between April and Nov...

French Aged Dop Hard

8.2 Great

10

Beecher's Flagship Reserve

American clothbound cheddar-style hard cheese from Beecher's Handmade Cheese, founded in Seattle in 2003, aged at least...

American Hard Cow Milk Clothbound

8.2 Great

11

Barber's 1833 Vintage Cheddar

Barber's 1833 Vintage Cheddar is a Somerset farmhouse cheddar produced by the Barber family since 1833, made with unpast...

British Aged Cheddar Hard

8.2 Great

12

Cabot Vintage Choice Cheddar

Aged cheddar from Vermont's Cabot Creamery cooperative, matured at least two years, offering a pronounced sharp flavor p...

American Aged Cheddar Hard

8.1 Great

13

Cantal Vieux

Cantal Vieux is one of France's oldest cheeses, a hard cow's milk variety from the Auvergne region aged for a minimum of...

French Aged Dop Hard

8.0 Great

14

Cougar Gold

American hard cheese developed at Washington State University in the 1940s and sold in distinctive 30-ounce sealed tin c...

American Artisan Aged Canned

8.0 Great

15

Laguiole

Laguiole is a firm French cheese from the Aubrac region, crafted from cow's milk and historically used to create the fam...

French Aged Dop Hard

7.9 Good

16

Sartori BellaVitano Gold

American hard cheese from Sartori Company in Plymouth, Wisconsin, known for its buttery, fruity flavor profile and a smo...

Modern American Fruity Hard

7.8 Good

17

Tillamook Aged White Cheddar

White cheddar from Tillamook County Creamery Association in Oregon, aged at least nine months, one of the Pacific Northw...

American Aged Cheddar Hard

7.4 Good

18

Wyke Farms Vintage Cheddar

English cheddar from Wyke Farms, a Somerset family farm dating to the 1800s, aged at least 12 months and recognized for...

British Aged Cheddar Hard

7.3 Good

19

Organic Valley Raw Sharp Cheddar

Organic Valley Raw Sharp Cheddar is a U.S. cheese made from unpasteurized organic milk by Organic Valley, a farmer-owned...

Organic American Cheddar Hard

7.1 Good

20

Belgioioso Parmesan

BelGioioso Parmesan is a Parmesan-style hard cheese produced by BelGioioso Cheese Inc. in Wisconsin, one of the largest...

American Branded Hard Cow Milk

6.8 Fair