swap_horiz Maytag Blue Alternatives

1

Rogue River Blue

Rogue River Blue is an American blue cheese produced by Rogue Creamery in Oregon. It’s notable for its unique flavor pro...

American Wrapped Oregon Cow Milk

9.6 Brilliant

2

Bayley Hazen Blue

Bayley Hazen Blue is a distinctive American blue cheese crafted by Jasper Hill Farm of Vermont. The cheese utilizes cow’...

American Artisan Vermont Cow Milk

9.3 Excellent

3

Kraftkar

Kraftkar is a distinctive Norwegian blue cheese produced by Tingvollost dairy. This artisan cheese utilizes cow’s milk a...

Norwegian Artisan Cow Milk Award Winner

9.1 Excellent

4

Blue Stilton

Blue Stilton is a classic cow’s milk blue cheese originating from Derbyshire, Leicestershire, and Nottinghamshire. Its p...

Classic Pdo Christmas English

8.9 Great

5

Calderwood

Calderwood is an American blue cheese produced by Jasper Hill Farm in Vermont. It’s notable for its intensely flavorful...

American Aged Vermont Cow Milk

8.9 Great

6

Rogue Creamery Caveman Blue

Rogue Creamery Caveman Blue is an American artisan blue cheese produced by Rogue Creamery in Oregon. This distinctive ch...

American Artisan Creamy Oregon

8.8 Great

7

Rogue Creamery Echo Mountain Blue

Rogue Creamery Echo Mountain Blue is an American artisan blue cheese produced in Oregon. It’s notable for its distinctiv...

American Artisan Aged Oregon

8.7 Great

8

Hook's Blue Paradise

Hook’s Blue Paradise is an American artisan blue cheese crafted by Hook’s Cheese Company of Wisconsin. This double-cream...

American Artisan Wisconsin Cow Milk

8.7 Great

9

Point Reyes Original Blue

A raw cow's milk blue cheese from Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese Company in Marin County, California, first produced aroun...

American California Artisan Cow Milk

8.6 Great

10

Devil's Gulch Blue

Devil's Gulch Blue is an American artisan blue cheese associated with Devil's Gulch Ranch in Marin County, California, a...

American California Artisan Cow Milk

8.6 Great

11

Rogue Creamery Smokey Blue

Produced by Rogue Creamery in Oregon, it is cold-smoked over hazelnut shells and is widely regarded as the first commerc...

American Artisan Oregon Smoked

8.4 Great

12

Point Reyes Bay Blue

A creamier, longer-aged blue from Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese Company in Marin County, California, developed as a compa...

American California Artisan Creamy

8.3 Great

13

Rogue Creamery Oregonzola

A Gorgonzola-style blue cheese made by Rogue Creamery in Central Point, Oregon, using locally sourced cow's milk in a tr...

American Artisan Oregon Cow Milk

8.2 Great

14

Consider Bardwell Dorset

A goat's milk blue cheese from Consider Bardwell Farm in West Pawlet, Vermont, named after the nearby town of Dorset and...

American Artisan Vermont Cow Milk

8.2 Great

15

Rogue Creamery Crater Lake Blue

A cow's milk blue cheese from Rogue Creamery in Central Point, Oregon, named after the state's famous volcanic crater la...

Classic American Artisan Oregon

8.0 Great

16

Berkshire Blue

An artisan blue cheese made in the Berkshire Hills of western Massachusetts, crafted in the style of English Stilton wit...

American Artisan Creamy Massachusetts

7.8 Good

17

Hook's Blue

Made by Hook's Cheese Company in Mineral Point, Wisconsin, it is a well-aged American blue from a producer celebrated fo...

Classic American Artisan Wisconsin

7.6 Good

18

Boucher Blue

An American artisan blue cheese produced in small batches by an independent creamery, crafted using traditional handmade...

American Artisan Vermont Cow Milk

7.6 Good

19

Great Hill Blue

Produced by Great Hill Dairy in Marion, Massachusetts, from raw whole cow's milk, it is among the few American blue chee...

American Artisan Massachusetts Cow Milk

7.5 Good

20

Bingham Hill Rustic Blue

A handcrafted blue cheese from Bingham Hill Cheese Company in Fort Collins, Colorado, a small-batch artisan producer kno...

American Colorado Artisan Cow Milk

7.2 Good