Judges Like George Sutherland
Pierce Butler
Judge
4.23
Poor
Willis Van Devanter
Judge
4.19
Poor
James McReynolds
Judge
1.93
Poor
John Marshall Harlan II
Judge
7.18
Good
Robert Jackson
Judge
8.69
Great
John Marshall Harlan I
Judge
8.60
Great
Joseph Story
Judge
8.42
Great
John Paul Stevens
Judge
7.96
Good
Harry Blackmun
Judge
6.67
Fair
Samuel Alito
Judge
6.35
Fair
James Byrnes
Judge
6.26
Fair
Tom Clark
Judge
5.98
Mediocre
Edward Sanford
Judge
5.89
Mediocre
Joseph Rucker Lamar
Judge
5.80
Mediocre
Stephen Field
Judge
5.70
Mediocre
Horace Gray
Judge
5.66
Mediocre
Mahlon Pitney
Judge
5.61
Mediocre
John H. Clarke
Judge
5.52
Mediocre
David Brewer
Judge
5.15
Mediocre
Frank Murphy
Judge
5.11
Mediocre
Samuel Blatchford
Judge
4.92
Poor
William Day
Judge
4.51
Poor
Lucius Quintus Cincinnatus Lamar
Judge
4.42
Poor
Rufus Peckham
Judge
3.86
Poor
