Best Car Insurance

Updated Daily emoji_events View Best Car Insurance Rankings
inventory_2 22 items
trending_up Scored across 12 criteria

Rankings use category fit, feature coverage, pricing signals, public reception, and recency. Affiliate relationships do not affect scores.

Filter by Tags
0.0 10.0
Best 1 State Farm
State Farm

State Farm remains a top choice in 2026 due to its extensive network of local agents providing personalized service and a strong financial foundation. Their 'Drive Safe & Save' program, leveraging tel...

9.66 Brilliant
Visit
2 USAA
USAA

USAA consistently ranks at the top of the industry for customer satisfaction and financial stability. Exclusively serving military members, veterans, and their families, USAA provides highly competiti...

9.55 Brilliant
Visit
3 GEICO
GEICO
From $12.95/mo or Free Trial

Geico is widely recognized for its aggressive pricing and ease of use. While Geico underwrites some policies, they often partner with other reputable insurance carriers to provide renters coverage, al...

9.53 Brilliant
Visit
4 Amica Mutual Insurance
Amica Mutual Insurance

Amica offers the standard menu of auto insurance coverage. For an extra cost you can upgrade to Platinum Choice Auto, a package that contains several coverage options, with details varying by state. I...

9.32 Excellent
Visit
5 Allstate
Allstate
From $13/mo or varies based on coverage and location

Allstate is a powerhouse in the insurance sector, known for its highly customizable policies and a wide array of discounts. Renters can tailor their coverage to include specific riders for jewelry, el...

9.26 Excellent
Visit
6 Nationwide Independent Agents
Nationwide Independent Agents

Nationwide Independent Agents is a car insurance provider that offers a range of policies, including liability and comprehensive coverage. Known for its network of independent agents who can provide p...

9.05 Excellent
Visit
7 Progressive
Progressive
From $15/mo

Progressive is a leader in the insurance market, particularly known for its 'Name Your Price' tool and extensive bundling options. For renters, Progressive offers a seamless digital experience that al...

9.02 Excellent
Visit
8 Shelter
Shelter
From $25/mo

Shelter car insurance comes with bodily injury and property damage liability, which are required by law in nearly every state in the country. For no additional cost, policyholders get Shelter's roadsi...

8.96 Very Good
Visit
9 Liberty Mutual
Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual offers a robust renters insurance product that stands out for its wide range of coverage options and potential for significant discounts. They are known for allowing renters to customiz...

8.89 Very Good
Visit
10 Travelers Insurance
Travelers Insurance
From $10/mo

Travelers Insurance offers Comprehensive Coverage that helps pay for damage to your vehicle that is not caused by a collision. For example, theft, vandalism, hitting a deer or other animal, storms and...

8.89 Very Good
Visit
11 Travelers Property & Casualty Company
Travelers Property & Casualty Company

Travelers Property & Casualty Company is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its strong financial stability and customer s...

8.75 Very Good
Visit
12 Nationwide
Nationwide

Nationwide is a well-regarded insurance provider that offers a balanced renters insurance policy with plenty of room for customization. They are known for their 'Brand New Belongings' coverage, which...

8.37 Very Good
Visit
13 SafeAuto
SafeAuto

SafeAuto distinguishes itself through its comprehensive telematics program, offering discounts based on a variety of driving metrics. Their system tracks speed, braking, and cornering, providing drive...

8.20 Very Good
14 Westfield Insurance
Westfield Insurance
From $20/mo

Westfield Insurance is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its competitive pricing and customer service, Westfield Insuran...

7.92 Good
Visit
15 American Security Insurance Group
American Security Insurance Group

American Security Insurance Group is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its competitive pricing and customer service, Ame...

7.91 Good
Visit
16 Mercury Insurance Company
Mercury Insurance Company
From $15/mo

Mercury Insurance Company is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its competitive pricing and customer service, Mercury Ins...

7.82 Good
Visit
17 Drivewise by Allstate
Drivewise by Allstate

Drivewise, Allstates telematics program, allows drivers to earn discounts by monitoring their driving behavior through the Allstate Mobile app. The app tracks factors like speeding, hard braking, and...

7.80 Good
18 Hartford
Hartford

The Hartford is well-known for their partnership with AARP, making them a popular choice for seniors and retirees. They offer a solid, reliable umbrella policy that is easy to understand and fairly pr...

7.55 Good
Visit
19 Travelers Casualty and Surety Company
Travelers Casualty and Surety Company

Travelers Casualty and Surety Company is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its competitive pricing and customer service,...

7.50 Good
Visit
20 Erie Insurance
Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance is a highly regarded regional provider known for its competitive pricing and excellent customer service. While they operate in a more limited geographic area than national giants, they...

7.37 Good
Visit
21 American Family
American Family

American Family Insurance, primarily serving the Midwest, offers competitive rates and family-focused coverage options. They maintain a strong commitment to local communities and provide personalized...

7.33 Good
Visit
22 National General Insurance Company
National General Insurance Company
From $20/mo

National General Insurance Company is a car insurance provider that offers comprehensive coverage options, including liability and collision. Known for its competitive pricing and customer service, Na...

7.17 Good
Visit
You've reached the end — 22 items

Save to your list

Create your first list and start tracking the tools that matter to you.

Track favorites
Get updates
Compare scores

Already have an account? Sign in

Compare Items

See how they stack up against each other

Comparing
VS
Select 1 more item to compare